Some even accused the judges of wasting the "judges' save" on contestant Casey Abrams instead of saving it on Toscano, whom the judges did appear to favor.
She impressed the judges with her rendition of "I'll Stand by You" during the semi-finals, receiving the first standing ovation of the season and earning her a place in the Top 13.The judges even said she had one of the best performances on the show in Idol history.A source says Haley is with Casey as “a revenge move to get back at Stefano.” To recap, we feel like we’re stuck in an episode of “As The World Turns” or something.Pia Ann Rose Toscano (born October 14, 1988) is an American singer from Howard Beach, New York.In 2006, she graduated from La Guardia High School of the Performing Arts in New York City.
Fellow Idol contestant Karen Rodriguez also attended this school.
Furthermore, Toscano performed the National Anthem and "I'll Stand by You" at the Memorial Day Concert in Washington, DC held on May 29, 2011.
Less than 24 hours after being eliminated from American Idol, Toscano was reported to have signed a recording contract with Interscope Records.
She made it through to Hollywood in Season 6, but was eliminated.
In 2010, she auditioned for the tenth season of American Idol in East Rutherford, New Jersey and was put through to Hollywood, this time making it through to the Top 24.
The 26-year-old has reportedly been on several Skype dates with “Twilight” star Nikki Reed, 22. Mc Donald isn’t the only contestant that seems to be a Twi-hard; Lauren Alaina and Taylor Lautner have reportedly crashed these Skype dates (Oh, teenagers), and Alaina appears to be smitten with the heartthrob. Because she sent the 19-year-old a heart-shaped signal on the Mar. Nothing says I like you like reminding your crush of the girl that dumped him (Hi, Taylor Swift! Now for some contestant-on-contestant crushes, Haley Reinhart and Casey Abrams are apparently hooking up…